Having read Paulo Freire’s ideas on The Banking Concept and Laurence Shames’ ideas on how our society has become the consumers we are, I have come to the conclusion that they both have very valid point.
Freire explains a “problem-posing” class must consist of teacher-students with student-teachers. There cannot be educators who think highly of themselves and see themselves as an authority figure. It is not impossible for the students to teach, but in order for the teachers to be taught they must make themselves vulnerable to the students. As Paulo Freire states “The students-- no longer docile listeners-- are now -- critical co-investigators in dialogue with the teacher”. In order for educators to learn from their students there must be communication involved on both ends. The teacher is expected to express their thoughts while the students brainstorm their own ideas and considerations.
Friere is lead to explain the banking concept as the teacher dictating information and the students passively receive that information and store for short term only. This processes that were put through is influencing how we act inside the classroom as well as outside. Since we were children through our adult hood we will be looked down upon by those of authority. The educators are preparing us to live our entire lives as receptacles. To just store the information that is handed to us and use it when necessary. This is how society runs, everywhere you look there are oppressed.
Shames’ points out, ever since the first frontier, Americans have always wanted more. We as humans automatically are drawn to consumerism. Once Americans came to the original frontier they were preoccupied by the idea of obtaining more and more wealth. Soon it became less about the quality of things and more of the quantity, “Expansion could remain a goal unto itself, and would continue to generate a value system based on bulk rather than on nuance, on quantities of money rather than on quality of life”.
Thursday, January 28, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment